Skip to Content

What Does Cauliflower Crust Pizza Taste Like?

This post may contain affiliate links and/or codes. You won’t pay anything extra, but I might make a commission.

Cauliflower Crust Pizza

So I’m doing this six-week low-carb experiment, and I think I’m hating myself more than the experiment.

 

OK, so, I’ve officially become that person who talks about being low-carb ALL the time. Is it mitigated at all by me hating it and not being all “You HAVE to go low carb! This is awesome sauce!!!!!” ? (Also, pretty sure I’m not allowed to eat awesome sauce.) ‪#‎CarbBreak2015‬

Posted by Amy Oztan on Thursday, April 2, 2015

The best part of the whole thing is the food suggestions I get from other people. Because A) People are nice and are trying to help me and B) I need to eat more than just salads and eggs or I’m going to go crazy and crash my car into an Olive Garden in the hope that my car flips a table and a breadstick accidentally lands in my mouth and in my panic, I chew it. (Totally not my fault! I panicked! I didn’t cheat!)

About a week ago someone suggested that I try cauliflower crust pizza (thanks Shannon!) and I was like Yeah, I don’t think so. That sounds a little too desperate.

Fast forward one pizza-free week and I was like “WHERE’S THAT RECIPE?” (If you google “cauliflower pizza crust” they’re all basically the same recipe.)

So, on the same night that I made actual pizza for my husband and daughter and calzones for my son, I made cauliflower crust pizza for myself. Big mistake, because making the cauliflower crust is way more involved than making actual pizza crust. So while the rest of my family ate around 8:15, my dinner wasn’t ready until 9:30. By that point I’d pretty much lost interest and could have gone to bed without dinner, but I’d gone through all that trouble, so I sat down with a slice.

Cauliflower Crust Pizza

It was fine. It looked and acted like pizza. I could eat it like a slice of pizza, no knife and fork.

But it tasted exactly how I thought it was going to taste: Like sauce and cheese on top of cauliflower. It tasted like the fact that I couldn’t eat real pizza.

And I think that’s my problem with most of the suggestions that I get for low-carb foods. They’re striving to replace other foods that I adore.

Things that are shaped like noodles are not pasta, in any way. Putting spaghetti sauce on them just reminds me that I can’t have pasta. I’ve tried spaghetti squash spaghetti. It tastes like spaghetti squash. Which is fine, but don’t suggest it to me as a “replacement” for pasta! There is NOTHING about it that is like pasta, except (sort of) the shape. And I don’t think that it lends itself all that well to red sauce. It’s not a great flavor combination. Never once have I had a low-carb acolyte suggest to me that I should roast an acorn squash and top it with red sauce. Because it’s the wrong shape, duh!

Cucumber slices and cottage cheese are not potato chips and dip. (Thanks for that one, Dr. Oz.).

Cauliflower in a bagel shape covered in everything bagel topping is not an everything bagel.

Cheesy mashed cauliflower is delicious, I’ve made it and loved it. But stop suggesting it as a “replacement” for mashed potatoes. The only thing they have in common is that they’re both white. (And mashed, I guess.)

Making cauliflower into a bread-slice shape doesn’t make it bread any more than making bacon into a bread-sliced shape would make it bread.

And seriously, what’s with all the cauliflower fake-outs? Is it because cauliflower is white? Because you can chop it up tiny and kind-of make it into a dough? I bet that would work with a lot of vegetables, but cauliflower has been designated the go-to low-carb imposter.

Trying to mimic one food with a totally different one sets me up for disappointment. On the other hand, good recipes that just happen to be low-carb get me excited.

I guess I just hate a bait-and-switch.

Would I be more open to things like cauliflower pizza crust and spaghetti squash spaghetti if I were doing this for longer than six weeks? Probably. But I’m not, so I don’t care. This is just about getting through the next 30 days.

Do I sound cranky? I am. BECAUSE I HAVEN’T HAD CARBS IN TWELVE DAYS.

Dean Thomas

Monday 6th of March 2023

I agree with you one hundred percent. When I started carb dieting, the main reason I couldn't stick to it was because I was trying to replicate my old diet with low carb replacements, and they just couldn't compare. I missed pizza, and pizza missed me. I couldn't stick to the diet until I just gave up on the things I used to love, and found new foods that I loved that just happened to be low carb.

kEn

Saturday 7th of September 2019

I think the author nailed it on the head when she said she doesn't care. As with anything in life, when you really want something you go for it, even if it tastes like shit.

Ben

Sunday 22nd of January 2017

I found this post because I feel the same way. Diet Coke tastes nothing like Coke and there is no way I can convince myself a cucumber slice is a tortilla chip. The idea that making something the same shape makes it equivalent is absurd to me. However, I was open to cauliflower pizza as I have two recent surprises in this "low carb" field that I would genuinely recommend.

First of all, I find cauliflower "couscous" is actually pretty good. Since couscous itself is pretty bland, most of the flavour comes from other things anyway, so doing it with cauliflower works fine and I'd be happy to eat that regularly.

Secondly, I find "spaghetti" made with courgette (zucchini to Americans) actually surprisingly good. I don't even like courgette all that much, but I find the texture isn't bad. It also works well for noodles. I find (if you can manage a few carbs) a mix of real spaghetti and fake spaghetti works quite well.

Nathan

Thursday 25th of February 2016

what is it with Americans and your total lack of taste when it comes to pizza (or anything else for that matter)

just sauce and cheese? who has "just a cheese" pizza? its mental. you've taken an italian culinary classic and made it duller than dishwater. ? Where are the onions?, peppers? mushrooms? rocket? olives? parma ham? sweetcorn etc etc

all things which would add flavour and texture while keeping it a healthy option.

all you done here is mashed up some cauliflower and added cheese to it. Well done.

Ben

Sunday 22nd of January 2017

Tell that to the Neapolitans!

D Cassell

Thursday 18th of August 2016

Um, Pizza was hardly Italian culinary. Pizza was pupular in Italy cause it was food for the poor, and started out as just crust and tomatoes close to be over riped

Darvin

Thursday 9th of June 2016

Thanks nathan you nailed it...I'm definitely making this but it will have more than jist heese and sauce

Hemz

Tuesday 16th of February 2016

Ok I actually enjoyed the honesty in this blog and loved your post. Not going to bother with cauliflower pizza- very valid points made. I once made zero noodles and they tasted like rubber :/

Amy Oztan

Wednesday 17th of February 2016

I should mention that I really liked the cauliflower grilled cheese. The flavors went together so much better.

Privacy Policy ~ Full Disclosure ~ Disclaimer